TOP 6 Areas Where to Stay in Door County + HOTEL GUIDE

Door County is an amazing peninsula located in Wisconsin between Green Bay and Lake Michigan. The area has become a super popular holiday destination for people around the US as well as international travelers so buckle up because I’m about to show you why!

No matter the season, this place offers incredible landscapes! Just picture tons of leafy parks, serene shorelines, and tranquility. And let’s not forget about that small-town charm you’ve got to love it!

In this post I will help you find all the best places where to stay in Door County. Below you will find a detailed list of the top hotels! Some may have tennis courts some a children’s pool but they all have one thing in common, amazing reviews! This is why I recommend booking in advance, Door County is super popular and touristic, so everything sells out fast.  

Let’s hit the road!

If you are in a hurry

Here’s a list of the best hotels if you want to book now. They’re all located in Sister Bay:

luxury hotel

The Dorr Hotel

Best luxury hotel

airbnb

Modern Apartment

An Airbnb with amazing reviews

mid-range hotel

Pheasant Park Resort

Best value for money

budget hotel

Open Hearth Lodge

Best affordable accommodation in the center

Here’s a map that will help you visualize all the areas where to stay in Door County:

Sister Bay
for first-timers
Egg Harbor
for budget
Green Bay
for families
Sturgeon Bay
for history lovers
Bailey’s Harbor
for outdoor enthusiasts

1. Sister Bay – where to stay in Door County for the first time

Are your bags packed? Because you’ll want to leave ASAP once you see how awesome this tiny village in Door County is! Home to one of the most popular beaches in the area, Sister Bay has all the ingredients you need for a successful trip!

Door County offers incredible scenery and you’ll get that and more in this lovely village, plus great restaurants, boutique stores, and many resorts! And if you’re into shopping, I recommend visiting Milwaukee, Wisconsin’s largest city!

Don’t be fooled by its size. Sister Bay is ready to take in a large number of tourists. However, you should book your hotels in advance because this area is super popular, and everything sells out so fast!

Ready to relax on the beach? Before that, let’s check out the hotels in Sister Bay.

Luxury hotel

Enjoy a quiet morning on the sun terrace of this hotel that has a fitness center and a bar. The rooms are equipped with a flat-screen tv and a seating area.

Other accommodation options in Sister Bay

Mid-Range

Feel at home in this resort that offers a hot tub, indoor and outdoor pools, and barbecue facilities

Budget

Warm-up by the fire pit at this lodge that has an indoor pool, picnic areas, and a children’s playground

Airbnb

Tucked away between the trees, this place has a great backyard, 4 rooms, and it offers beach access

Things to do in Sister Bay

  • Try the go-karts at Johnson’s Park
  • Visit the Sister Bay Historical Society
  • Relax on Sister Bay Beach
  • Spend a fun day at Pirate’s Cove Adventure Golf
  • Check out the art at Frykman Studio Gallery

2. Fish Creek – best area for visiting Peninsula State Park

Located 9 miles (14 km) southwest of Sister Bay, this village is a great place to stay in Door County for people who want to visit the Peninsula State Park.

Fish Creek is a tranquil place, perfect for people looking to escape the city noise, couples, and nature lovers. It’s also great if you like spending time outdoors, engaging in all sorts of activities by foot or by bicycle in Peninsula State Park.

But don’t hurry to the Park so fast, Fish Creek has 2 fabulous beaches from where you can admire the best views of Lake Michigan. Plus a cool house museum if you’re into history and want to learn more about the town’s past!

Luxury hotel

Enjoy the harbor views from the comfort of your room which has a flat-screen tv and air-conditioning. You will also find a terrace and an outdoor fireplace where you can gather up at night!

Other accommodation options in Fish Creek

Mid-Range

This motel is located near the beach and it has a garden, family rooms, and private parking  

Budget

Featuring both an indoor pool and an outdoor pool, this Fish Creek hotel offers a game room and a library

Airbnb

An elegant studio that has a balcony with a seating area, a kitchen, and which offers free parking

Things to do in Fish Creek

  • Explore around Pennisula State Park, near Eagle Harbor
  • Catch a sunset at Sunset Beach Park
  • Visit the Alexander Noble House Museum
  • Enjoy the lake views at Fish Creek Beach
  • Play golf at the Peninsula State Park Golf Course
  • Go wine tasting at Lautenbach’s Orchard Country Winery

3. Egg Harbor – where to stay in Door County on a budget

Welcome to the little town of Egg Harbor, Door County’s most quiet village! This place is perfect if you want to enjoy some peace and quiet during your trip but it also offers a wide range of budget accommodations.

Located a 30 minutes drive away from Sister Bay, Egg Harbor is not as popular as the other villages in Door County so you should note that might not find as many facilities. But when you’ve got access to so many natural spots, what else would you need?

Yep, this village is also great for nature lovers, as is most of the areas in Door County. Here you can sunbathe on the beach, play golf and drink lots of wine!

Luxury hotel

I so love this place! It’s super bright, with big windows and a terrace that’s perfect for late nights and drinking wine by the fireplace. The accommodation has 3 rooms and a kitchen, perfect for a lovely weekend away!

Other accommodation options in Egg Harbor

Mid-Range

Relax by the fireplace or use the complimentary bikes to explore around at this resort with a heated outdoor pool

Budget

A great Egg Harbor resort that offers a children’s play area, barbecue facilities, and 2 swimming pools

Airbnb

This apartment has an interesting futuristic design and it’s equipped with a kitchen and free wifi

Things to do in Egg Harbor

  • Go wine tasting at Harbor Ridge Winery
  • Sunbathe on Egg Harbor Beach
  • Take a stroll around Heritage Lake
  • Play golf at The Orchards in Egg Harbor
  • Explore the Forest State Natural Area

4. Green Bay – best place to stay in Door County for families

Although not technically part of Door County, Green Bay serves as its gateway and it’s located on the southern tip of Lake Michigan, a bit further away from Sister Bay (75 miles or 120 km to be more exact).

It’s an excellent place for families as the city is a bit bigger and it offers a broader range of attractions that I’m sure the kids will love. There are also many museums and shopping stores for the grown-ups to enjoy!

If you enjoy having something to do at all times, I think you’ll like Green Bay. The Amusement Park has so many rides that you won’t know where to begin! And let’s not forget about the Botanical Garden, which is so charming. It looks as if fairies live there!

Luxury hotel

Order breakfast in the room and enjoy a lazy morning at this Green Bay hotel with a game room, a terrace, and a fitness center.

Other accommodation options in Green Bay

Mid-Range

A hotel that offers a complimentary breakfast, an indoor pool, and rooms for families

Budget

This budget accommodation has family rooms equipped with a flat-screen tv and free wifi

Airbnb

I like how comfortable and cozy this place looks! It has 2 spacious rooms, a backyard, and a kitchen

Things to do in Green Bay

  • Spend a fun day at Bay Beach Amusement Park
  • Admire the flowers at Green Bay Botanical Garden
  • Spot cute animals at Wildlife Sanctuary
  • Visit The Children’s Museum
  • Check out the rollercoaster at Zippin Pippin

5. Sturgeon Bay – where to stay in Door County for history

Located 30 miles (50 km) south of Sister Bay, Sturgeon Bay offers the most amazing views, and it’s also a great place where you can learn more about the area’s maritime history.

There’s a picturesque lighthouse, and the river views are simply stunning. I also recommend exploring the historic district that it’s both business orientated and residential.

With a wide range of accommodation and places to dine (you can even attend a live music show at places like Waterfront Mary’s restaurant), Sturgeon Bay will become one of your favorite spots in Door County!

Luxury hotel

I love the decor of this Sturgeon Bay B&B! It has that vintage inn kind of theme going on! Grab a cup of tea and relax by the fireplace in the seating area.

Other accommodation options in Sturgeon Bay

Mid-Range

This adult-only accommodation offers rooms with private bathrooms and  many off-site activities

Budget

Gather up by the fire and make new friends at this Sturgeon Bay hotel that has family rooms

Airbnb

A super cozy cottage perfect for 2 guests, that has a kitchen and a shared backyard

Things to do in Sturgeon Bay

6. Baileys Harbor – the best place to stay for outdoor enthusiasts

Located only 9 miles (15 km) away from Sister Bay, this town is perfect for those who like going off the beaten track and spending time in nature.

Baileys Harbor also hosts Wisconsin’s most famous brewery, the Door County Brewery Co. Where you can go to have a delicious beer and listen to some live music as well! That’s if you’re not out there exploring the woods.

There are tons of places that you can explore here, like Toft Point State Natural Area or The Ridges Sanctuary, both offering great walking paths!

Luxury hotel

Head to the tennis court or golf course if you’re up for some exercise! This accommodation even has a sun terrace and an outdoor fireplace, where you can chill.

Other accommodation options in Baileys Harbor

Mid-Range

A beachfront accommodation that offers a lot of water sports facilities on-site and a heated outdoor pool

Budget

Relax in the indoor heated pool at this resort that has family rooms and a picnic area

Airbnb

I like the whole design of this house that offers lake access, 4 rooms, a kitchen, and a backyard

Things to do in Baileys Harbor

  • Go for a walk around The Ridges Sanctuary
  • Have a beer at Door County Brewery Co
  • Explore the Toft Point State Natural Area
  • Spend a fun day at Lakeshore Adventures Zipline
👑 Luxury price:$180
💵 Mid Range:$140
🛏️ Budget:$80
🏠 Airbnb:$180
💰 Accommodation prices:Medium
📍 Best area:Sister Bay
👪 Best area for families:Green Bay
🛎️ Best luxury hotel:The Dorr Hotel
💵 Best mid-range hotel:Pheasant Park Resort
👛 Best budget hotel:Open Hearth Lodge

Frequently asked questions about Door County

🌳 What is the best town to stay in Door County?

Sister Bay is the best town to stay in Door County as it offers many attractions, easy access to the other towns, and great hotels such as The Dorr Hotel.

📆 What is the best time to visit Door County?

The most popular time for a Door County visit is May through October. Spring offers the beauty of apple and cherry blossoms and wildflowers.

🌊 What is Door County known for?

Door County is known for its picturesque coastal towns, specialty shops, fish boils, cherry and apple orchards, and scenic beauty.

🏖️Does Door County have beaches?

Yes, Door County has a few beaches. Some of the best ones are Sister Bay Beach and Fish Creek Beach.

Conclusion

What a stunning location! I hope this post helped you decide where to stay in Door County!

There are so many hotel options in the post, and it’s so hard to make a decision, so here are my top 2 favorite accommodations both located in Sister Bay:

Just remember that these are Door County’s best accommodation so booking in advance will help you secure the best spot!

Enjoy the views of the Green Bay waters, and if you have any questions, leave me a comment below and I’ll answer it ASAP!

Safe Travels,

Victoria

Disclaimer: Please note that some of the links on this page might be affiliate links, which means that at absolutely no extra cost for you we will earn a small commission for a sale generated through the website. We only recommend the things we actually use ourselves and never accept useless sponsored crap. Thank you so much for supporting this project!

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Follow @misstourist on Instagram!