Best Airbnbs in New York City – 11 Stunning and Unique Rentals

Looking for the best Airbnb in New York City for your upcoming trip? The city is home to a selection of great Airbnb rentals – but some are a cut above the rest. In this post, I’ve put together a list of the coolest and most unique accommodation options available. 

New York really needs no introduction. As a cultural melting pot, historical centerpoint, urban marvel, and pop-culture paradise, it’s an outstanding city by practically every measure. Each year, many millions (yes, millions) of tourists flock to the city for a taste of The Big Apple.

Among its historic streets and futuristic structures, you can discover a myriad of flavors, find endless entertainment, and shop yourself silly. The nightlife is non-stop, the landmarks are iconic, and the scenes are wonderfully diverse.

As if that wasn’t enough, the city offers some stunning rentals for all tastes and budgets. The best Airbnbs in New York City can transform your vacation experience.

NOTE: For some great insights into the city’s best neighborhoods, be sure to check out this guide

If You Are in a Hurry: Top rated Airbnbs in New York

Looking for a quick fix? Here are the best four Airbnbs in Manhattan’s finest neighborhoods. They’re all as central as can be and sorted by price for your convenience. 

luxury hotel

Luxury Loft in SoHo

Luxury loft apartment in the center

airbnb

Luxury Townhome in the Center

Mid-price Airbnb in the center

mid-range hotel

Private Studio in Brooklyn

Budget apartment in the center

budget hotel

Cozy Room in East Village

Budget room in the center

NOTE: Extending your trip to include Philly? Check out this guide on where to stay while you’re there.

Top 11 Airbnbs in New York City

After searching high and low, and sifting through the abundance of Airbnbs in New York, I finally arrived at this distilled list of stunners. 

To make things easier, I’ve calculated the average price per night for a three-night stay at each property, by including cleaning fees and other costs. So you can see what you’ll really be paying.

The list is also sorted by price (high to low) to keep your search nice and simple. So let’s dive in.

1. Luxury Loft Apartment in New York City

where to stay in new york with familyLuxury Loft Apartment in New York Citybest area to stay in new york for the first time
  • Price: US$1770
  • Bedrooms: 1
  • Guest: 4

You can play hide and seek in this extremely spacious (215 sqm) luxurious apartment in the heart of Soho. Yes, that’s how huge the place is, which is rare to find in the city. With soaring ceilings, and exposed brick and piping, you’ll feel like you’ve stepped into a designer version of Andy Warhol’s studio.

It’s not only spacious and well-designed but also has practical features like a full chef’s kitchen as well as a washer and dryer for your laundry. On top of all that, it has a private rooftop deck all to yourself. What more could you wish for?

2. Architect Loft – A Stylish Apartment in Manhattan

Architect Loft - A Stylish Apartment in Manhattanwhere to stay in new york citywhere to stay in nyc for broadway shows
  • Price: US$920
  • Bedrooms: 1
  • Guest: 3

With its high ceilings, thriving plants, and vintage furniture, this loft’s living room is an oasis of comfort after wandering New York’s streets all day. Bohemian accents like surfboard decoration and beachy wooden accents, and hammocks contribute to the overall feel.

Feel free to get some work done as the place has an internet and two comfy working desks. Afterward, you can enjoy a home-cooked meal at the hefty stone table and gather around with friends on the sofa watching movies.

3. Brooklyn Brick & Brownstone – A Modern Masterpiece for Groups

  • Location: Brooklyn
  • Price: from US$940 per night
  • Bedrooms: 5
  • Guests: 10

Nestled on a tree-lined Brooklyn street, this modern, five-bedroom home is stunning from top to bottom. With an artist and an architect as its owners and designers, the Airbnb will strike you with splashes of art and design. 

You’ll be in the heart of Brooklyn, surrounded by funky cafes, small stores, and plenty of restaurants. And just a subway ride away from the likes of Times Square in Manhattan. 

After a day of exploring, head up to your own private terrace for a sunset drink in the trees. With high-end amenities and a queen bed in each room, everyone in your group will be in for a great night’s sleep.

4. Luxurious 2-bedroom Apartment – Centrally Located

where to stay in New York for luxuryLuxurious 2-bedroom Apartment in New York - Centrally Locatedwhere to stay in near Central Park
  • Price: US$850
  • Bedrooms: 2
  • Guest: 4

Stylish, luxurious, and conveniently located – people say you can’t have it all, but checking out this property will prove them wrong! This apartment is centrally located, well-furnished, and spotlessly clean, with great views of the Hudson from all three rooms. 

This 2-bedroom apartment is perfect for small families visiting New York. The kitchen is stocked with everything you might need, and the rooms are quiet at night. Plus, you’ll have easy access to attractions like Central Park, Time Square, Empire State, Rockefeller center, Hudson Yards, and more.

5. 5 Million Dollar Townhouse – Perfect for Large Groups

  • Location: Harlem
  • Price: from US$500 per night
  • Bedrooms: 5
  • Guests: 13

It’s exceedingly rare to find a place in Manhattan with as much space as this wonderful home. If you’re the claustrophobic type, you’ll feel as comfortable as ever among the lofty ceilings, spacious rooms, double-height windows, and backyard.

The wooden floors are warm underfoot and the chef’s kitchen will be a dream if you’re a passionate cook.

Step out onto the secluded wooden deck in the backyard for candle-lit dinners, evening drinks, or delightful breakfasts among the trees. Or hop on the subway to reach any one of Manhattan’s attractions in around 15 minutes.

6. The Louvre Meets The Heart Of The East Village – Quirky Airbnb Apartment in the Center 

  • Location: East Village
  • Price: from US$260 per night
  • Bedrooms: 1
  • Guests: 2

Located in the core of the lively and ever-popular East Village, this charming apartment is a dream for history buffs and admirers of European culture. Historic paintings, furniture, and decor pepper the space and make for a curious stay. But the real magic with this Airbnb apartment is being so close to the best of everything NYC has to offer.

You’ll feel like you’re staying in an Airbnb apartment in Paris until you step out right into the heart and soul of New York City. With one bedroom, one bathroom, and excellent amenities, it’s the perfect spot for a loved-up couple. 

7. Cozy, Quintessential Brooklyn Carriage House – Perfect Studio for Cozy Couples

  • Location: Brooklyn
  • Price: from US$240 per night
  • Bedrooms: 1
  • Guests: 3

With a private entrance and bathroom, air conditioning, wood-beamed ceilings, and plenty of charm, this modern studio Airbnb is perfect for a happy pair. You’ll want to melt into the luxurious queen size bed, but try to resist; the best of Brooklyn will be at your doorstep.

The tiny house is located in the celebrated Boerum Hill area, just a brief walk from all subway lines and a wealth of things to do.

Start your day off right with some sunrise yoga using the mats and equipment provided before heading out to explore New York City at its best.

8. Budget-friendly Apartment in Harlem

where to stay in new york city on a budgetBudget-friendly Apartment in Harlemwhere to stay in new york manhattan
  • Price: US$155
  • Bedrooms: 1
  • Guest: 4

A perfectly budget-friendly apartment in the heart of Harlem. Expect a fully-furnished condo where you can cook to save some money, or if you prefer to dine out, there are plenty of restaurants nearby. This place has free WiFi too! 

You will be staying at the garden level (ground floor), and for privacy, you have a separate, private entrance. Also, the hosts live upstairs and are more than happy to assist you throughout your stay.

9. Private Studio Apartment – Minutes to the Airport

airbnb new york studio apartmentPrivate Studio Apartment in New York - Minutes to the Airportwhere to stay in new york near the airport
  • Price: US$133
  • Bedrooms: 1
  • Guest: 4

Catching an early flight? To save time and energy, I found you a chic apartment in Queens, just 2 blocks from LaGuardia airport. With parking and a private entrance, you will have the apartment to yourselves. 

With its theme and colors, the space looks classy and cozy at the same time. Technically the place has one bedroom with a queen-sized bed, however, the living room sofa can be converted to a sofa bed for an additional two guests.

10. Modern Rooftop Loft with City Views – Budget-Friendly Airbnb for a Pair of Friends

Modern Rooftop Loft in New York with City Viewswhere to stay in New York on a budgetBudget-Friendly Airbnb in New York for a Pair of Friends
  • Price: US$100
  • Bedrooms: 1
  • Guest: 2

This apartment loft is designed to impress, from the layout, and choice of furniture to the modern decor. Your room is filled with natural light from the large glass windows overlooking Brooklyn. 

If you plan to stay in this luxurious yet budget-friendly apartment, please note that this is a walk-up building, so there’s no elevator, and the loft is on the 4th and 5th floors. Either you pack light or think of it as exercise and don’t mind walking up and down the stairs.

11. Sunny, Modern Room in East Village! – Charming Spot with a Rooftop

  • Location: East Village
  • Price: from US$110 per night
  • Bedrooms: 1
  • Guests: 2

Looking for a sunny, central spot to rest your head? This comfortable private room is part of a stunning duplex in East Village. You’ll be sleeping in a queen-size bed, facing a window that pours in the sunlight. 

The apartment is peppered with plants and it has an almost unbelievable private terrace. Here, you can sink into deluxe outdoor furniture and enjoy the sunset with views of the city skyline.

You’ll also be treated to a quirky kitchen, a beautiful shared bathroom, and a TV equipped with entertainment galore.

BONUS: Best Airbnbs Around New York City

While NYC is a vibrant destination filled with life and energy, sometimes a bit of peace and escapism is the right medicine. 

Fortunately, NY State is home to some incredibly unique getaway homes. Here are some of the coolest Airbnbs around NYC, with driving times included.

1. Willow Treehouse – Secluded, Unique, & Romantic

  • Location: Willow (driving time from NYC: 2 hours)
  • Price: from US$470 per night
  • Bedrooms: 1
  • Guests: 2

Slide into your own secluded slice of nature with this spectacular treehouse Airbnb in Willow. It’s a truly unique Airbnb space that’s part-log cabin and part-utopian sci-fi structure.

Perched on the edge of a natural, swimmable pond, and encircled by trees, you’ll feel at one with nature without foregoing your favorite creature comforts.

There’s a reason why the living room couch faces the windows rather than a TV; the views are out of this world. You’ll find your eyes glued to the glass for hours on end as you stoke the indoor fireplace and cozy up with some wine.

2. A Black A-Frame – Sustainable Catskills Cabin

  • Location: Kerhonkson (driving time from NYC: 1 hour 45 min)
  • Price: from US$390 
  • Bedrooms: 2
  • Guests: 4

Nestled in the Catskill Mountains, at the end of a secluded, forested road, you’ll see this dreamy, two-bedroom Airbnb in the woods. 

The New York Post called it ‘New York’s coolest A-frame’ for good reason. It’s a clean, off-grid, solar-powered gem that immerses you in stunning natural surroundings and caters to every comfort. 

Fire up the outdoor grill and light up the fire pit for a magical evening beneath the stars. Or, in the colder months, get busy in the chef’s kitchen and enjoy your meal amid the splendor of the dining room’s original woodwork.

3. The Glass House – A Hudson Valley Tiny Home Escape

  • Location: Marlboro (driving time from NYC: 90 minutes)
  • Price: from US$390 per night
  • Bedrooms: 1 
  • Guests: 2

In recent years, publications and press, from the New York Times to The Today Show, have featured this unique Airbnb for its almost-unreal aesthetic allure. With three walls of glass, air conditioning, and an impeccable design (inside and out), the place is small but stunning.

You may have seen pictures of it floating around social media and thought of it as a fantasy place. Yet it’s available for booking on Airbnb, and impressively close to NYC.

Enjoy the seclusion of having a 30-acre farm as your backyard. Cozy up in the luxury queen size bed with a view, cook up a treat in the fully stocked kitchen, or huddle around the fire pit for s’mores.

Top 4 Airbnb Experiences

Airbnb Experiences are a perfect way to get to know a city with a passionate, local host. Here are some of the best experiences available in NYC.

  1. Cycle through Central Park – Discover the beauty and hidden treasures of Central Park with the wind in your hair.
  2. See 30+ top New York City sights – This five-hour tour of NYC shows you some of the city’s best highlights, including Times Square to Central Park. 
  3. Taste your way through New York’s sandwiches – On this top-rated tasting tour, you’ll journey through the city with your host, tasting three of the finest sandwiches it has to offer.
  4. Take a tour of Chinatown & Little Italy – Your host will share stories about the people who immigrated to New York from Italy, Ireland, and China on this tour, and how they shaped the city. 

Conclusion

New York will sweep you off your feet with its lively atmosphere, endless things to see and do, and stunning places to stay. If you want to stay in one of the best Airbnbs in the city, be sure to book it swiftly. The coolest spots get booked up fast!

For a classy group vacation, I recommend that you book Brooklyn Brick & Brownstone. It’s flawlessly stylish, clean, and plenty large, as well as being located close to the heart of Brooklyn’s action.

If you’re a budget-conscious couple, check out this Private Studio Apartment, Bath, & Balcony. It’s a slick, central studio that’s impressively easy on the wallet.

Whether you’re after a loft on the Lower East Side, a cozy cottage outside the city, or a groovy apartment in Brooklyn, Airbnb has an option for you! 

Have you stayed in New York Before? If so, I’d love to hear your thoughts and recommendations in the comments section below. I hope you have a wonderful and safe trip that leaves you smiling long after you return home.

Disclaimer: Please note that some of the links on this page might be affiliate links, which means that at absolutely no extra cost for you we will earn a small commission for a sale generated through the website. We only recommend the things we actually use ourselves and never accept useless sponsored crap. Thank you so much for supporting this project!

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Follow @misstourist on Instagram!